Doing Dickens – Part 10

I feel monumentally befuddled by Bleak House, the tenth book in our attempt to read all of Charles Dickens’s novels. Despite it being acknowledged by pretty much everyone as one of his greatest books, I just didn’t like it as much as I wanted to (I am imagining cries of ‘boo’ and ‘shame’ in my fantasy world where leading cultural figures read this blog). I’m not even sure why I felt this way. To misquote Churchill, it is a mystery within an enigma wrapped in utter confusion.

There’s so much to admire in Bleak House – the opening, with its one-word sentence, ‘London’, is one of the most powerful things I’ve read; the descriptions of a cannibalistic legal system and a society that’s decaying at every level, from crumbling mansions to the squalid Tom All-Alone’s, are poetic and visceral; the dark, bitter rage at injustice is more profound than the youthful anger of Oliver Twist. On all these levels, it is a masterpiece. Yet, somehow, there’s not so much to love.

The Preface describes this novel as ‘impenetrable’, but I found the people, rather than the plot, closed-off. Nearly everything we’ve read so far, even the slight duds (sorry Dickens), have featured characters with that flinging-themselves-off-the-page, grabbing-you-by-the-throat quality. But here even tragic chimney sweep Jo, Shakespearean fool Miss Flite or spontaneously-combusting Krook felt like a less satisfying version of someone I’d encountered before.

Is it because we’ve been reading Dickens in chronological order and have to get used to a more mature, subtle characterization in his big ‘condition-of-England’ novels, and wave goodbye to the exuberance? Are ideas and mood rather than character his main priorities in this book? I’d love to know what anyone else who has read Bleak House thinks. Here are the views of our esteemed panel:

‘I found Bleak House brilliantly easy to read, but in retrospect complex and hard to get a grip on. It's sort of despairing but sort of very funny, the characters are deep psychologically but I didn't feel for them deeply. I'll remember it for the vividly drawn places, such as the oppressive inns of court in sweltering midsummer, and the terrible slums where the rotting buildings crash down suddenly around the inhabitants' ears. It's a novel of eeriness, suspicions and mystery, and of people being driven mad by the system. The detective novel aspect is fantastic and I also enjoyed to trying to guess which character was going to spontaneously combust. The book is like the labyrinthine staircases in the eponymous Bleak House itself, which so intrigue and baffle its dwellers; I think if I read it five times I'd see a different novel each go around.’  Becky Stocks

‘As ever with Dickens, the opening chapter is wonderful: evocative, engaging, and full of brilliantly coloured characters. The world of Chancery is painted perfectly, giving a wonderful, terrible impression of the nightmare the suitors faced. And the characters are, of course, great: the self-effacement and gentle wisdom of Esther, the kindness of John Jarndyce, the useless charity of Mrs Jellyby, the oozy disgustingness of Krook and the rootless determination of poor Richard. And yet - I didn't find it as effective as some others we've read. Bleak House had a cynicism and a grimness to it which meant it was hard to engage with the story, and Lady Dedlock, long held up as a masterpiece of 'women in literature', seemed like a less-well drawn, less convincing version of Dombey and son's Edith. Still a masterpiece, but only third place in our chart so far. An impressed but unmoved 8.2/10.’  Sam Binnie

I’m hoping that the rest of the books we read will provide further illumination on Dickens’s progression as a writer. Next time – Hard Times. 

Louise Willder, Copywriter

 

 

Comments

[Jane Brocket]

I am really enjoying reading about your Dickens marathon. You all write so well about the books: vividly, directly, and very honestly. I was delighted that you thought Dombey and Son highly underrated (it's probably my favourite), and agree that there is something about Bleak House that eludes even the most enthusiastic reader of Dickens.

I just wanted you to know that it's a pleasure to read the posts, and that the vast investment of time and thought that you've all made has not gone unremarked. Not many more to go now.

Thanks.

Jane

[Amanda]

Hi,

I've also been eagerly following your posts, but I have to disagree with your and Jane's impressions above, since Bleak House is my favorite Dickens so far (I've read Dombey and Son, Bleak House, Hard Times, A Tale of Two Cities, Great Expectations and some of the Christmas books. Little Dorrit and David Copperfield are next in my list). I suspect reading order might have something to do with it, because the feeling some of you had when comparing it to Dombey is exactly the feeling I've had while reading Dombey (my most recent Dickens read), but regarding Bleak House. I'm glad you enjoyed it, though, and can't wait for your next posts!

Amanda

[Louise the copywriter]

Thanks both of you Jane and Amanda, I'm glad to hear you're enjoying the posts and, more importantly, enjoying your Dickens reading! I'm sure reading order counts, as many people I've spoken to have said Bleak House was one of the first Dickens they read, and their favourite. I'm glad to hear it's not just us though Jane! Louise

[Jeremy Scott Wings]

I can't believe how much of this I just wasn't aware of. Thank you for bringing more information to this topic for me. I'm truly grateful and really impressed.

[green smoke brand]

A great website with interesting and unique material what else would you need.

[Air Yeezy 2]

Rock under the grass to teach us strong, to teach us wild lilies cliff dedication, and the mountains of pine trees to teach us hard rain, the cold weather bloom teach us Xiaoying snow.

[Swiss A. Lange Sohne Watches]

Such children may be seen to exhibit certain complications in their ability to develop certain skills required for daily functionality.

[Adidas Bounce]

This is a great inspiring article. I am pretty much pleased with your good work. You put really very helpful information. Keep it up.

[Bookkeeping Services Sunshine Coast]

Part 1O makes me feel that I want part 11. Dickens you ruled my world today. Thanks for the book!

[The Adventures Of Guys]

I am so glad to see this. Meat definitely needs to be cooked to a certain point. This is not good for you when it is not cooked to this point.

[grey hair]

Keratin is a strong protein that is found in skin, hair, nails and teeth.

[luke]

Thanks for the post
http://opzionibinarie.tuttoforex.net
http://opzionibinarie.mondoforex.com
http://www.mondoforex.com
http://www.tuttoforex.net

[Restposten Filialisten]

Die Frage, wo Wiederverkäufer aus dem Restposten und Sonderposten Handel Ihre günstigen und sehr billigen Waren herbekommen und diese gewinnbringend verkaufen?
ist nicht so einfach zu beantworten, wenn man nicht über die richtigen Kontakte zum
Restposten und Sonderposten Grosshandel verfügt. Sie möchten durch den Grosshandel Restposten und Sonderposten sowie Direktimport haupt- oder nebenberuflich ein gesichertes lukratives Einkommen dauerhaft erreichen? Aber wie erhalte ich die besten Kontakte zum Restposten und Sonderposten Grosshandel? Welche Warenangebote gibt es dort? Auf http://www.nulleurocent.de erhalten Sie sämtliche Informationen rund um den Restposten und Sonderposten Grosshandel völlig kostenlos http://www.33web.de

[Ryan Gosling drive jackett]

Thanks for such an outstanding post and the assessment, I am absolutely impressed! Keep aspects this coming.

[Liam Neeson Jacket]

Thanks for trying to discuss about this, I encounter extremely about it and really like learning more on this topic.

[apps for iphone]

Bleak House is one of recommendable book by Dickens. It's worth reading!

[Mulberry Outlet UK]

Andrew Bailey earned his 24th save, No. 75 of his career to tie Jason Isringhausen

[swarovski purse]

me and patners really enjoyed your blog and its very nice one. many of the peoples con get many information from your blog

[Oliver Nickels]

Many thanks for sharing this post, greetings from hamburg in germany
http://www.tarif-king.de
http://www.pferdeboxen-schilder.de

[Tina]

Some posts really matters because they are valueable, I have found your post very valueable.

[boise blinds]

Charles Dickens is one the greatest writers of all time. I wish that more kids today had the inclination to read the classics. I know I didn't when I was a kid but later in life I learned to love these books.

[Handbags]

I have a bought nice handbag.To use the bag is very comfortable.To get more versos information.Please visit: http://www.walletsnhandbags.com/

[Handy Flatrate]

Many thanks for sharing this useful article but missing visual parts. http://www.kostenlose-simkarte.com
http://www.bundlesbilliger.de

[garage door repair phoenix]

Wow, this is pretty interesting. Inspiring, as well. Thanks for sharing such inspiring experience with us. Great blog, congrats.!

[andsonjhon]

Hey, nice blog with good info. I really like coming back here often. And wish you would create more such interesting blogs.
San Diego Human Resource Company

[San Diego HR Company]

Great post about this. I am sure many visitors will find this very useful.

[water softeners]

Pretty good post. I found your website perfect for my needs. Thanks for sharing the great ideas.

[Handyvertrag Vergleich]

Thanks for sharing this useful article. A great blog with inspiring informations in a clear design, well done and greetings http://www.dualsim-handyshop.de

[resident evil 6 alternate costumes]

It's gracefull to see what i was searching for. That's the material which I was searching about. The matter you've highlighted above is surely valueable for anyone to workout. the concept of your article is very true and It will result in a positive way. Thanks you very much for sharing this with us.

[san diego human resources]

I appreciate the work of all people who share information with others. Great Blog!

[cheap apartments in mesa az]

I found lots of interesting information here. The post was professionally written and I feel like the author has extensive knowledge in this subject.

[SEO Expert]

Glad to read your post :). It is very informative!

[bestellen longchamp taschen]

Hi nice post.I like your information. I have been looking for this type of information that is interesting and good.